Salicylic Acid reacting differently from each manufacturer

[PoppyLady]

Hi, I am very ignorant in the mysteries of chemistry and am attempting to find a supplier of salicylic acid for my home made glycerine soaps.  I have run batches with percentages from .5% to 2%.  

Between suppliers the end result is very different in;

• strength: measured by the dryness experienced by those who used it
• fragrance: (note my test batch soaps are un-fragranced. However the normal natural fragrance was changed by both suppliers in different ways.  For one supplier it seemed there was no longer any fragrance, for another it had a mild unpleasant chemical smell.
• hardness: both suppliers created a harder dryer soap than without SA. One was harder than the other.
• clarity:  Note that I only used clear soap in one test for one supplier.  Within a few days the clear soap was almost undistinguishable from a normal white soap (Titanium Dioxide is used for a whitener)

I will say that my soap is very finicky.  I have had suppliers change their sorbitol process/ingredient for example and it ruined batches of soap.  I am using the standard (non-pharmaceutical) SA. If anyone can tell me why different manufactures are behaving differently I would greatly appreciate it. 

[vincent9874]

The differences in salicylic acid’s performance from various suppliers could be due to variations in purity, the presence of different impurities, or slight differences in the chemical composition. These factors can affect the strength, fragrance, hardness, and clarity of your soaps. It’s important to ensure that the salicylic acid you purchase meets the same specifications for your soap-making needs to achieve consistent results.

[susan789wolfe]

Thank you for helping people get the information they need. Great stuff as usual. Keep up the great work!!!

[sollani]

---

@alexcareyhales wrote:

---

@PoppyLadynjmcdirect wrote:

Hi, I am very ignorant in the mysteries of chemistry and am attempting to find a supplier of salicylic acid for my home made glycerine soaps.  I have run batches with percentages from .5% to 2%.  

Between suppliers the end result is very different in;

• strength: measured by the dryness experienced by those who used it
• fragrance: (note my test batch soaps are un-fragranced. However the normal natural fragrance was changed by both suppliers in different ways.  For one supplier it seemed there was no longer any fragrance, for another it had a mild unpleasant chemical smell.
• hardness: both suppliers created a harder dryer soap than without SA. One was harder than the other.
• clarity:  Note that I only used clear soap in one test for one supplier.  Within a few days the clear soap was almost undistinguishable from a normal white soap (Titanium Dioxide is used for a whitener)

I will say that my soap is very finicky.  I have had suppliers change their sorbitol process/ingredient for example and it ruined batches of soap.  I am using the standard (non-pharmaceutical) SA. If anyone can tell me why different manufactures are behaving differently I would greatly appreciate it. 

---

When salicylic acid reacts differently depending on the manufacturer, several factors could be contributing to the variance:

1. Purity and Grade: The purity of salicylic acid can vary between manufacturers. Impurities or different grades (e.g., pharmaceutical vs. industrial) can affect the reaction outcomes.
2. Particle Size: The physical form, including particle size and crystallinity, can influence how salicylic acid dissolves and reacts.
3. Additives: Some manufacturers might include additives or stabilizers that could affect the reactivity.
4. Storage Conditions: Differences in storage and handling conditions (e.g., temperature, humidity) could alter the chemical properties over time.

To identify the cause, consider obtaining detailed product specifications from the manufacturers, conducting controlled experiments, and performing purity tests.

---

Thanks, its a great help for me to react salicylic acid.